He broke up with his fiancée and also her $53,000 ring. A New York State Supreme Court judge ruled a man who broke up with his future bride via a text message relinquished his right to reclaim her nearly 3-carat engagement ring, reports the Buffalo News.
Louis J. Billittier Jr. sued his former fiancée Christa M. Clark after the 38-year-old nail technician refused to give him back the four-prong diamond engagement ring, the newspaper reported,
He broke off their 14-month relationship in July 2012, leaving Clark incredulous.
“Your doing this through a text message????” she replied.
Under state law the spouse is entitled to recoup the ring, but not when they imply it’s a gift, ruled State Supreme Court Justice Russell P. Buscaglia last week, according to the newspaper.
“Plus you get a $50,000 parting ring. Enough for a down payment on a house,” the 55-year-old texted next.
During the November trial Billittier, who broke off the engagement because Clark refused to sign a prenuptial agreement, said he sent that text as a joke, the newspaper reported.
“I was being sarcastic, like a game show host – you get a parting gift,” Billittier said.
But the judge ruled the texts show he meant for the ring to be a gift.
“Many gifts are given for reasons that sour with the passage of time. Once a gift is given, it is irrevocable.”
“Parting gifts on game shows usually pale in comparison to the grand prize sought in such contests, unlike here where the ring is at the heart of this lawsuit,” Buscaglia said.
The judge pointed to other text messages Billittier sent after the breakup.
“Keep it up, and I will take back the ring as well,” he texted her.
He sent a final text message on July 31 requesting the ring be returned.
“You by law have to give it back,” he texted. “You’re nowhere near the person I thought you were. You don’t deserve it.”
The judge ruled the text showed he changed his mind and had “giver’s remorse.”
Attorneys for both sides declined to comment to the newspaper after the ruling.
“Many gifts are given for reasons that sour with the passage of time,” the judge ruled. “Once a gift is given, it is irrevocable.”
firstname.lastname@example.org Follow on Twitter @joelzlandau
If you’re looking for money for diamonds, either through wedding ring consignment or if you just want to sell your diamond jewelry outright, then we are happy to introduce you to Diamond Lighthouse. We have developed a platform that provides you the best way to sell your diamond, hands down. We don’t buy diamonds, we help you sell unwanted diamonds for the most money possible. We take a commission from the sale (10% on diamonds 1 carat and higher), so we always strive to get you the most money possible when you sell diamonds online. Through a sophisticated digital system, we are able to present your diamond jewelry to a vetted network of professional diamond buyers and dealers. The buyers and dealers then compete for your diamond jewelry in an open auction. Diamond Lighthouse informs you, the diamond owner, of the highest offers and you are free to pick (or reject) the highest one. It simply is the most efficient and superlative way to sell diamond jewelry online. From start to finish, the entire sale can transpire in a few days; much, much quicker than regular diamond consignment (and far more profitable too, as most diamond consignment shops take a commission of 50 percent).
Find out more info on our company here – and learn the absolute best way to sell your diamond.